- Books

The Heebie-Jeebies at CBGB's: A Secret History of Jewish Punk #2020

The Heebie Jeebies at CBGB s A Secret History of Jewish Punk Based in part on recent interviews with than people among them Tommy Ramone Chris Stein Blondie Lenny Kaye Patti Smith Group Hilly Kristal CBGBs owner and John Zorn this book focuses on pun

  • Title: The Heebie-Jeebies at CBGB's: A Secret History of Jewish Punk
  • Author: Steven Lee Beeber
  • ISBN: 9781556526138
  • Page: 485
  • Format: Hardcover
  • The Heebie-Jeebies at CBGB's: A Secret History of Jewish Punk By Steven Lee Beeber, Based in part on recent interviews with than 125 people among them Tommy Ramone, Chris Stein Blondie , Lenny Kaye Patti Smith Group , Hilly Kristal CBGBs owner , and John Zorn this book focuses on punk s beginnings in New York City to show that punk was the most Jewish of rock movements, in both makeup and attitude As it originated in Manhattan s Lower East Side iBased in part on recent interviews with than 125 people among them Tommy Ramone, Chris Stein Blondie , Lenny Kaye Patti Smith Group , Hilly Kristal CBGBs owner , and John Zorn this book focuses on punk s beginnings in New York City to show that punk was the most Jewish of rock movements, in both makeup and attitude As it originated in Manhattan s Lower East Side in the early 1970s, punk rock was the apotheosis of a Jewish cultural tradition that found its ultimate expression in the generation born after the Holocaust Beginning with Lenny Bruce, the patron saint of punk, and following pre punk progenitors such as Lou Reed, Jonathan Richman, Suicide, and the Dictators, this fascinating mixture of biography, cultural studies, and musical analysis delves into the lives of these and other Jewish punks including Richard Hell and Joey Ramone to create a fascinating historical overview of the scene Reflecting the irony, romanticism, and, above all, the humor of the Jewish experience, this tale of changing Jewish identity in America reveals the conscious and unconscious forces that drove New York Jewish rockers to reinvent themselves and popular music.

    • [MOBI] È The Heebie-Jeebies at CBGB's: A Secret History of Jewish Punk | By ☆ Steven Lee Beeber
      485 Steven Lee Beeber
    • thumbnail Title: [MOBI] È The Heebie-Jeebies at CBGB's: A Secret History of Jewish Punk | By ☆ Steven Lee Beeber
      Posted by:Steven Lee Beeber
      Published :2020-01-04T02:54:01+00:00

    1 thought on “The Heebie-Jeebies at CBGB's: A Secret History of Jewish Punk

    1. When I saw the title of this book, I nearly plotzed I became a punk new wave fan in 1976 1977, during my freshman year at Brandeis, when my classmate Neil Kaplan younger brother of Ira Kaplan, the soon to be frontman of Yo La Tengo , played me the compilation record Live From CBGB s and Television s Marquee Moon, the latter of which quickly became one of my 2 or 3 favorite records of all time see, e.g my profile picture on , in which I m wearing the cover art of that album on my t shirt I was ho [...]

    2. I read this at the same time I read Please Kill Me, and that s actually something I think everyone should do Or, if you are not someone who reads multiple books at once, you should read these close together They complement one another extremely well That one s the oral history, the dirt and the gossip and who s fucking whom in which bathroom while on what drugs this one is the background, the influences, the history and the culture that made that other book possible While you re at it, read Men [...]

    3. Starts out making a somewhat interesting argument about the influence of Jewish culture on Punk before devolving into all sorts of speculation and some fairly insulting, preposterous notions Nazi obsessed Ramones Johnny and Dee Dee are de facto Jews because they grew up in as minorities in a largely Jewish enclave.rding to Beeber, being alienated or marginalized in any way is synonymous with Jewdom The turning point comes when Richard Hell ne Myers objects to being included he was raised in Kent [...]

    4. Jewish punk Who knew I d never thought about it, or noticed it before But, yeah, punk is a Jew thang Great interviews Very well written Never boring And, I LEARNED SO MUCH

    5. I ve been wanting to read this for almost 10 years, and it was only at the end of last year that I finally managed to get hold of a copy Two copies, to be precise a book I got via interlibrary loan and a new purchase Imagine how excited I was.And what can I say it was well worth the wait As expected, I wasn t too happy with the chapter on English punk and how non American contributions in general are downplayed or neglected I recently stumbled across the Peruvian proto punk band The Saicos, for [...]

    6. The best thing about this book is the title it s quite witty Trying to convince readers that if it wasn t for Judaism, Lenny Bruce or Hitler, there wouldn t have been punk rock, or that if he hadn t been Jewish, Joey Ramone wouldn t have become the Godfather of punk is a real stretch In fact, most of the book reads like a compendium of castoff lines from Seinfeld or Shecky Greene it s our musicality and punkishness that has sustained us as a people for 2000 years The Yiddish expressions througho [...]

    7. You know that feeling you have when, say, you know someone well, but then you meet their family and they make sense, have a context I felt like this book did that for the New York ans a bit of the British punk scene It showed how many of these people were already apart from mainstream society before they ever became musicians Plus, I loved the quotes from these rockstars where they used Yiddish.

    8. Steven Beeber has written the music book I ve been waiting to read From Lou Reed ne Lou Rabinowitz to Blondie s Chris Stein, Punk Rock s Jewish roots are vitally important but have been too long ignored Beeber has the music scholarship and the writing chops to create a vital and compelling read I couldn t put it down The Heebie Jeebies at CBGB s is a must have for every serious music lover.

    9. It was so enjoyable to learn some of the historical background and theories behind the slam dance between Jews and Punk Rock Growing up as a suburban Jewish NY teen, I was nourished by The Ramones, Blondie, Richard Hell and the Voidoids, countless other bands your book was a unique take on the post modern Jewish experience.

    10. The main argument found in Steven Lee Beeber s Heebie Jeebies is hinged on two main points First, Jewish Americans played a pivot role in the formation of not only the punk rock movement, but in American and Western music as a whole Second, that this is an overlooked secret To the first part I say duh and to the second I say well I guess it s not such a secret I was unaware that not only scholars, but people in general were ignorant to the prominence of Jewish Americans in music history and popu [...]

    11. i really tried to like this book, especially since the subject matter is very near and dear to my heart but frankly i was very disappointed, most of the material seems like a rehashing of what i had read in Please Kill Me except this author is trying to convince you of his theory that Judaism played a key role in the creation of punk of course i want to buy into this theory with every ounce of my heart, but the poor writing, repetitiveness of each chapter and some sort of naivete that comes from [...]

    12. FIVE STARS for this bold and surprising read Through a combination of original interviews and archival research, Beeber uncovers the hidden in plain sight Jewish origins of American punk rock, wittily examining the lives and lyrics of artists such as Lou Reed, the Ramones, and Jonathan Richman the Modern Lovers Carefully researched and compulsively readable.

    13. Thought I knew a lot about punk til I read this book It s fascinating, but the last few chapters lag compared to the earlier ones The book inspired me to rummage through itunes trying to find those albums artists that interested me most A must read for music fans

    14. I went through a Punk Rock phase a long time ago, never fully realized that it was largely a Jewish movement Very well written and insightful.

    15. I ve just begun the book.ough I have already flipped through it Fascinating to see what musicians real names are I ll be back

    16. I was SO EXCITED for this topic, and I was equally disappointed I struggled to get through the intro, and couldn t finish the first chapter The author makes assertions and rather than explaining them with facts evidence research etc just kind of explains them with further barely connected assertions I would do anything for someone to take this topic on again who is a better writer, or has even the slightest bit of academic inclination or really it felt like anything could have improved this book [...]

    17. The musician cast is the same as in McNeil and McCain s Please Kill Me but instead of entertaining the reader with stories of punks and pre punks shooting up on the stairs, getting the clap, cross dressing, and stabbing Nancy Spungen, this book argues that the Jewish background of the subjects is responsible for Punk as a significant aesthetic and cultural movement Given the stories recounted in Please Kill Me it seems like a stretch to say that Jewish influence is somehow to be blamed for the a [...]

    18. Steven Beeber interviewed scores of NY punk new wave scenesters including pre , post , etc about the influence of Jewish American culture This is good stuff it turns out that for some of these people there was an influence, it s been little discussed previously Now for the book s flaws The editing is sound as far as grammar fact checking goes but readability would have been improved by simply crossing out the many repetitions of anecdotes, descriptions, phrases quotes, which reappear from chapte [...]

    19. I like punk, but I m not Jewish Let me start off my review that way.I ve read a good deal about being Jewish, and I have many friends who are Jewish, but it s hard to see punk being the domain of anyone other than the socially, or emotionally, alienated, regardless of ethnicity.The foundation of this theory is a bit shaky The Ramones were undeniably punk, but others he cites as major influences were minor or rather, they were major influences in the New York punk scene, but not London s, or LA s [...]

    20. Like many other reviewers, I too really wanted to agree with the argument of this book I think the premise is flawed, though As Beeber says over and over in the book According to Lenny Bruce, if you re Catholic in NYC, you re Jewish paraphrasing It s easy to conflate being Jewish and being a New Yorker But, the sound and attitude were first cultivated by the MC5, Stooges, and lesser known Death all from Detroit and none Jewish Okay, their manager was Jewish it s a far cry to say his Jewishness m [...]

    21. An analysis of Punk rock that takes the position that Punk sprang from Jewish angst Beeber covers Jewish influences such as Lenny Bruce and Lou Reed as founding reasons for a subsequent wave of Jewish punk rockers While Joey Ramone, Richard Hell, Chris Stein just to name a few were Jewish this seems a forced dissertation for a movement that had to happen Disco, prog rock and self indulgent arena rock with those endless drum solos were the real cause of Punk That some of Punk s best were from New [...]

    22. This book was overall awesome and had some really interesting ideas explanations of the use of swastikas and discussions of the holocaust, connections between jewish comedians radical activists and punk music, etc but it had a couple of huge problems The first problem was that it was EXTREMELY repetitive some quotes had to have been used at least 4 times, often within paragraphs of each other and the second problem was that Beeber was super loose in his definition of Jewish Dee Dee and Johnny Ra [...]

    23. Interesting idea about jewish influence in punk music in New York I think the author stretches his case too far including saying that London punk is also jewish influenced because Malcolm McLaren sex pistols manager is jewish There is some new information in the book but at times seems too strident This book is only recommended for people already informed on the topic of New York punk music.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *